# Comparing two renovation quotations, item by item
Two totals can only be compared if the contractors have priced the same work. Provide a common description, compare the services and obtain missing details in writing before choosing. An absent item remains 'to be clarified': it means neither that the work is included nor that it is excluded.
## Have the contractors received the same request?
For a home in Wallonia, 'renewing the floors' can cover very different work. Our method is to give contractors the same available plans, photographs, areas and references. Describe the rooms, existing floor covering, desired finishes and known constraints: an occupied house, furniture to move, access or features to retain.
If the condition of the substrate is unknown, ask the professional to clarify the visit or assessment needed and its cost. Ask each quotation to state its assumptions. An identified uncertainty is better than a seemingly firm amount based on different information.
## Which items should you compare?
The [FPS Economy](https://economie.fgov.be/fr/themes/ventes/contrats/devis) explains the information in a quotation, including details of services and supplies, the fixed or determinable price, its validity and the estimated duration of the service. For a practical comparison, add a row per item and per room to your own checklist.
- Quantity and unit: floor covering area or skirting length, without confusing them.
- Supply: material, reference, characteristics and finish.
- Installation: substrate preparation, laying, junctions and touch-ups.
- Ancillary services: protection, removal, transport, waste and cleaning.
For each row, note 'included' if the quotation confirms it, 'excluded' if it expressly rules it out and 'to be clarified' if the text does not allow a conclusion. Keep the passage supporting that reading. This checklist is a comparison method, not a statutory form or a technical assessment.
## How can you use this checklist in a practical example?
Take an illustrative example, with no prices or real company. Quotation A lists the supply and laying of a floor covering, with substrate preparation and skirting. Quotation B mentions only supply and laying. This does not prove that B excludes the other work: ask for confirmation and any additional costing.
Also check that references and quantities match. A different finish remains a difference to examine, even if the totals are close. Ask the professional to explain alternatives rather than assuming they are equivalent.
## Are prices and timetables based on the same assumptions?
Distinguish a fixed price from items depending on a provisional quantity or calculation criterion. Ask how that quantity will be checked and which price will apply if it changes. Do not complete a quotation yourself with an assumed cost: ask the contractor for a price.
Have the total payable and stated taxes clarified on a comparable basis, without using this comparison to infer the applicable VAT treatment. Compare the validity of the quotations, the estimated duration of the work, the proposed start date and payment stages. A duration does not guarantee a start date.
## Which questions should be resolved before signing?
### What should you ask about an undescribed service?
Ask a precise question: 'Are substrate preparation, skirting and disposal included? Please detail the services and price any additions separately.' Adapt the list to the differences actually found.
### Is an oral explanation enough?
Request a completed quotation or written clarification attached to the offer. [ConsumerConnect](https://consumerconnect.be/fr/themes/construction/habitation/construction-ou-renovation/elaboration-d-un-devis) points out that a signed quotation or order form has the status of a contract. Clarify important points before committing yourself.
### Should you choose the lowest total?
Not automatically. Compare the current versions and the work needed to achieve the desired result, including anything still to be assigned to another contractor. Your checklist guarantees neither the future quality of the work, its technical compliance nor its final cost.
Keep the chosen quotation and written clarifications in the house file. If the work is preparing a sale, distinguish your own practical needs from work useful to its presentation. Our [guide to preparing a sale](https://youhome.immo/en/journal/preparing-house-sale-wallonia/) helps you organise the other documents; you can also [request your valuation report](https://youhome.immo/en/valuation/request/) to put these choices in the context of your project.
Practical guides
Comparing two renovation quotations, item by item
Services, quantities, finishes and conditions: compare two renovation quotations on the same basis before choosing an offer.



